Which Potato for What? Cooking Types, Varieties and Tips

Potato salad that falls apart or mash that won’t turn creamy: most of the time it’s the wrong potato. Here I explain what to look for when shopping, which variety suits what, and how to prepare and store potatoes properly.

In short: What matters is the cooking type. Use waxy potatoes for salad and fried potatoes, all-rounders for almost everything else, and floury (starchy) potatoes for mash, dumplings and soups. Store potatoes cool, dark and dry, but not in the fridge.

The three cooking types

In Germany every bag states one of three cooking types. It tells you how much starch the potato has and how it behaves when cooked. In the US, potatoes are grouped the same way, just under different names.

Cooking typeHow it behavesBest forUS examples
waxy (festkochend)holds its shape, slices cleanly, rather moistpotato salad, fried potatoes, gratinred potatoes, fingerlings
all-purpose (vorwiegend festkochend)slightly floury, rarely bursts, all-rounderboiled potatoes, roast potatoes, fries, stewsYukon Gold
floury/starchy (mehligkochend)falls apart easily, fluffy, absorbs lots of liquidmash, dumplings, soups, potato pancakesRusset, Idaho
The cooking types of potatoes and what they’re best for

Popular German varieties

The variety mainly decides color and flavor. You’ll often find these in German supermarkets:

VarietyCooking typeWhat makes it special
Lindawaxydeep yellow, buttery, full-flavored
Annabellewaxydelicate, slightly nutty, often sold as new potato
Sieglindewaxyclassic salad potato
Belana, Nicolawaxyyellow flesh, mild, good for salad
Gala, Marabel, Granolaall-purposeversatile for every day
Agriaall-purposelarge tubers, ideal for fries and roast potatoes
Lauraall-purposered skin, savory
Adrettaflouryfull-flavored, very fluffy
Afra, Augustaflourygood for mash and dumplings
Popular German potato varieties and their cooking type

Rinsing, soaking, peeling

  • Rinse raw pieces: for fries, pan-fried potatoes made from raw and oven potatoes, rinse the cut pieces briefly in cold water and dry them well. This washes off starch, so they don’t stick together and get crispier.
  • Don’t rinse: for rösti, potato pancakes, mash and dumplings you need the starch to bind.
  • With skin: potatoes boiled in their skins for potato salad (they absorb less water), new potatoes, baby potatoes and oven potatoes. Only eat the skin of fresh, undamaged potatoes.
  • Without skin: boiled potatoes, mash, dumplings and soups.

Green spots and sprouts

The skin, green spots and sprouts contain solanine. In larger amounts this natural compound can cause stomach pain and nausea, and cooking doesn’t destroy it. So generously cut away green spots and eyes. Potatoes with many green spots, long sprouts or a bitter taste don’t belong in the pot anymore. For small children, it’s best to peel potatoes.

How to store potatoes

  • Cool, dark and dry, ideally at about 45–50 °F (6–10 °C) in a cellar or a storage box.
  • Not in the fridge: below about 40 °F (4 °C) starch turns into sugar. The potatoes taste sweetish and brown faster when fried.
  • Don’t store them next to apples, which make potatoes sprout faster.
  • Light turns potatoes green, so don’t keep them in a plastic bag in a bright room.

New potatoes or storage potatoes?

New potatoes reach the shops from around May. Their skin is thin and easy to rub off, the flesh is moist and rather waxy. They only keep for a few days. Storage potatoes are harvested in autumn, have a firm skin and keep until spring if stored well.

FAQ

Why does my potato salad fall apart?

Usually floury potatoes were used. For salad, choose waxy varieties, boil them in their skins and peel them afterwards.

Why is my mash gluey?

A blender or immersion blender releases too much starch. Use a potato ricer or masher and floury potatoes instead.

Do I start potatoes in cold or boiling water?

Cold. That way they cook evenly from the outside in. Add the salt to the water right away.

Can I still eat sprouting potatoes?

If the potato is firm and the sprouts are still very short, cut them out generously and peel the potato. Discard potatoes with long sprouts or that are shriveled and green.

Matching recipe: Potato Salad with Herbs. You’ll also find short tips under letting potato salad marinate and potato ricer in the Kitchen A–Z.

Sources

You might also like