Baking Christmas cookies is fun, but the effort only pays off if they stay crisp or nicely soft until the holidays. A few simple rules make that easy, no special equipment needed. And if something has gone hard or soft after all, it can usually be saved.
In short: Let cookies cool completely and store each kind separately in a tight-fitting tin in a cool place. Crisp and soft cookies never go in the same tin. Most keep for 3 to 4 weeks this way, gingerbread even longer. A pound cake stays moist for 3 to 4 days when well wrapped, and cakes with cream or quark belong in the fridge.
The most important rules
- Let them cool completely: Warm cookies create condensation in the tin and turn soft. Ideally leave them on the rack overnight.
- Keep each kind separate: Soft cookies give off moisture, crisp ones absorb it. In a shared tin the crisp ones go soft. Strongly spiced cookies like gingerbread get their own tin too, otherwise everything tastes of cinnamon and cloves.
- Let icing and chocolate set: Only put them in the tin once everything is dry. Place a sheet of parchment paper between the layers so they don’t stick together and break less.
- Cool, but not in the fridge: A cool spot like a basement, pantry or unheated room is ideal. In the fridge, cookies absorb moisture and odors.
Which tin for which cookies?
Crisp cookies such as butter cookies, spritz cookies or vanilla crescents go in a tight-fitting metal tin. Metal keeps out light and air better than plastic, and the cookies stay short and crumbly.
Soft cookies such as gingerbread, macaroons or amaretti should stay moist. They also go in a metal tin or a tight-fitting plastic container. A piece of apple on a little parchment paper releases moisture and keeps them soft. Replace it every 2 to 3 days so it doesn’t go moldy. Soft cookies stay soft longest in an airtight container.
How to store cake
- Pound cakes and loaf cakes such as marble cake or banana bread keep for 3 to 4 days at room temperature. Wrap them in plastic wrap or put them under a cake dome. The cut side dries out first, so press it against the wrap or the plate.
- Fruit cakes such as apple cake taste best on the first and second day. Cover them only loosely, airtight packaging makes the base soggy from the fruit.
- Cakes with cream, quark, custard or cream cheese belong in the fridge and keep there for 2 to 3 days.
- Yeast pastries such as cinnamon rolls are best fresh and dry out quickly. Whatever you don’t eat on the first day is best frozen right away.
How long does it keep?
| Bake | Keeps for | Storage |
|---|---|---|
| Butter cookies, cut-out cookies | 3–4 weeks | metal tin, cool |
| Spritz cookies, vanilla crescents | 3–4 weeks | metal tin, layers separated with parchment |
| Gingerbread (Lebkuchen) | 6–8 weeks | own tin, a piece of apple keeps them soft |
| Macaroons, amaretti | 2–3 weeks | tight-fitting tin |
| Soft cookies | about 1 week | airtight container |
| Jam-filled cookies | 2–3 weeks | soften over time |
| Cookies with cream or cream cheese filling | 2–3 days | fridge |
| Pound cake, loaf cake | 3–4 days | wrap or cake dome |
| Fruit cake | 1–2 days | loosely covered |
| Cake with cream or quark | 2–3 days | fridge |
| Yeast pastries | 1 day | then freeze |
Freezing cookies and cake
Almost all cookies and cakes freeze well and keep for about 3 months in the freezer. Freeze cookies in a tin or freezer bag. To thaw, leave them closed at room temperature so no condensation forms on them. Cake is best frozen in slices, so you only take out what you need.
Bakes with sugar icing or meringue don’t freeze as well because they turn sticky, and neither does anything with whipped cream. A handy trick for the holiday season: cookie dough also keeps for about 3 months in the freezer. That way you can prepare at your own pace and bake fresh whenever you have time.
Gone hard or soft? Here’s how to save them
- Crisp cookies have gone soft: Re-bake on a baking sheet at 150 °C (300 °F) conventional heat for about 5 minutes and let them cool on a rack. They’ll be crisp again.
- Gingerbread has gone hard: Put a piece of apple in the tin for 1 to 2 days. After that they’ll be soft again.
- Cake is dry: Toast slices briefly and eat them with butter, or crumble the cake and layer it in a dessert with yogurt or quark and fruit.
Frequently asked questions
Usually they weren’t completely cool when you put them in, or they share a tin with soft cookies. Let them cool fully and store crisp and soft kinds separately.
Better not. In the fridge they absorb moisture and odors. Only cookies with cream or cream cheese filling belong in the fridge.
The apple releases moisture and keeps soft cookies like gingerbread moist. It’s not for crisp cookies. Replace the piece of apple every 2 to 3 days so it doesn’t go moldy.
About 3 months. To thaw, leave them in the closed tin at room temperature.
Did something go wrong while baking? Quick help is in Baking first aid. You’ll find more quick tips in the Kitchen ABC.










